Black Tulip: The Life and Myth of Erich Hartmann, the World's Top Fighter Ace

Available instantly

Audiobook
$0.00
with membership trial

Hardcover
$29.22

Paperback
$16.88

Your audiobook is waiting!

Click above for unlimited listening to select audiobooks, Audible Originals, and podcasts.
One credit a month to pick any title from our entire premium selection — yours to keep (you'll use your first credit now).
You will get an email reminder before your trial ends.
$14.95 a month after 30 days. Cancel online anytime.

Learn more about membership

Sold and delivered by Audible, an Amazon company

List Price: $17.19

By completing your purchase, you agree to Audible’s Conditions Of Use and Amazon's Privacy Notice.

Sold and delivered by Audible, an Amazon company

Black Tulip: The Life and Myth of Erich Hartmann, the World's Top Fighter Ace Audible Audiobook – Unabridged

Erik Schmidt (Author), Keith Sellon-Wright (Narrator), Tantor Audio (Publisher)

3.7 235 ratings

See all formats and editions

With over 1,404 wartime missions, Erich Hartmann claimed a staggering 352 airborne kills, and his career contains all the dramas you would expect. There were the frostbitten fighter sweeps over the Eastern Front, drunken forays to Hitler's Eagle's Nest, a decade of imprisonment in the wretched Soviet POW camps, and further military service during the Cold War that ended with conflict and angst.

Hartmann was adopted by a network of writers and commentators personally invested in his welfare and reputation. These men, mostly Americans, published elaborate, celebratory stories about Hartmann and his elite fraternity of Luftwaffe pilots. Hartmann's legacy became loftier and more secure, and his complicated service in support of Nazism faded away. A simplified, one-dimensional account of his life has gone unchallenged for almost a generation.

Black Tulip locates the ambiguous truth about Hartmann and so much of the German Wehrmacht in general: that many of these men were neither full-blown Nazis nor impeccable knights. They were complex, contradictory, and elusive. This book portrays a complex human rather than the heroic caricature we're used to, and it argues that the tidy, polished hero stories we've inherited about men like Hartmann say as much about those who've crafted them as they do about the heroes themselves.

Listening Length

9 hours and 10 minutes
Author

Erik Schmidt
Narrator

Keith Sellon-Wright
Audible release date

February 23, 2021
Language

English
Publisher

Tantor Audio
ASIN

B08WGJ733S
Version

Unabridged
Program Type

Audiobook
See all details

Report an issue with this product or seller

Read & Listen

Switch between reading the Kindle book & listening to the Audible audiobook with Whispersync for Voice.
Get the Audible audiobook for the reduced price of $7.49 after you buy the Kindle book.

People who viewed this also viewed

Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1

People who bought this also bought

Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1

Related to this topic

Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1

Product details

Listening Length	9 hours and 10 minutes
Author	Erik Schmidt
Narrator	Keith Sellon-Wright
Whispersync for Voice	Ready
Audible.com Release Date	February 23, 2021
Publisher	Tantor Audio
Program Type	Audiobook
Version	Unabridged
Language	English
ASIN	B08WGJ733S
Best Sellers Rank	#115,591 in Audible Books & Originals (See Top 100 in Audible Books & Originals) #89 in Air Forces Military History #94 in Aviation & Nautical Biographies #120 in World War II Biographies

Customer reviews

3.7 out of 5

235 global ratings

How customer reviews and ratings work

Sort reviews by

Top reviews from the United States

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

CDM

A Very Different Aviation Biography

Reviewed in the United States on July 1, 2020

Verified Purchase

There is a lot I could say about this book; how it is unlike any German aviator's biography I've ever read; how it got to the crux of something that has been increasingly nagging at my mind for some time now, and that I could never quite adequately describe; how it left me feeling. Instead of reading all that, I'd rather you read this book instead - particularly if you're a Second World War aviation enthusiast (I am). There are indeed some technical errors in the text, but this isn't a technical book. There are plenty of those available. This is a book about context and complexity, it embraces ambiguity and refuses to come to neat conclusions. In the end the picture of Hartmann is complicated, human, realistic, unflinching, respectful, and tragic. Highly recommended.

2 people found this helpful

Helpful

Hartmann is complicated. It's about time someone elaborated.

Reviewed in the United States on July 2, 2020

Verified Purchase

Sometimes, examination of a microscopic detail can illustrate a much larger image. Such is the case in this thoroughly researched biography of Erich Hartmann, the WW II pilot with the greatest number of kills. Hartmann dispatched more than 300 enemy airplanes while flying missions for Germany's Luftwaffe, more than double the war's next most successful pilot, and in general terms, ten times as many as an average pilot flying for any country during the war. Hartmann's unchallenged ability to knock an airplane out of the sky depended upon incredible close-flying skill, devastating sneak attacks, point-blank firing, and rapid escape to avoid hurtling shrapnel.

Hagiographers on both sides of the Atlantic have elevated Hartmann to idol status in the subsequent decades; a dueling knight of chivalry and honor. Which is why Schmidt's detailed analysis is so timely and important. Hartmann, after all, was flying in support of Hitler's offensives on the Western Front, the Eastern Front, and in support of a home bent upon extermination and annihilation of non-Aryan Europeans.

Beginning with an interrogation of Hartmann's own opinions regarding Nazism, Anti-Semitism, and nationalism (Hartmann left behind such a thin trail of interviews it is hard to say for certain to what degree he ever questioned the reason he was flying so many missions), Schmidt moves on to the more problematic question of Hartmann's over-the-top, post-war biographers. A great many have claimed to admire Hartmann through a finely-focused military lens, insisting their admiration is apolitical. Schmidt rightly points out that any historian claiming to ignore politics is in fact making a political decision.

Hartmann, skilled as he was, battered by ten years in Russian postwar detention camps, was in the end flying in support of Nazi world domination.

3 people found this helpful

Helpful

Marie

Not about Erich Hartmann. Its a magazine article judging Germans by American 2020 moral standards.

Reviewed in the United States on November 9, 2020

Verified Purchase

3/4 of the book is crude and poorly presented with minimal effort, and uses Erich Hartmann as clickbait for financial gain. I will admit that the last 1/4 of the book is an interesting and deep discussion regarding German cooperation and guilt for the conduct of the Third Reich. While I do not agree with Schmidt's conclusions, namely that we should judge everyone in history based on our Modern American Morality, the final 50 pages are well put together and seem to be deeply researched and do not involve Erich Hartmann at all. The first 150 pages are terrible. It is worse than what a child would present for a book report. And that is what it feels like, like Schmidt spent 18 months writing 50 pages about German remorse and guilt. But then had to cram 150 pages worth of writing before a deadline. The inconsistencies, poor grammar and structure flaws are like having teeth pulled. One highly memorable example: Schmidt introduces you to Alfred Hartmann, Erich's father, then seamlessly continues rattling on about Alfred (Jr.), Erich's younger brother, without once ever mentioning that; A: Erich had a younger brother, or B: that the brother's name was Alfred. Another example, Schmidt gives a simple explanation to the differences between BF109 and ME109. It's a simple and straightforward answer he gives, but it will do. But then he continues and says BF109 for the rest of the book. Outside of training, Erich Hartmann only ever flew the ME109G. These may seem trivial, but the first 150 pages are packed full of these errors. Which makes me wonder, was Schmidt so pressed by his deadline that he couldn't click 'spell check'? Or have someone proofread his slop? All this can be forgiven if some good conclusion can be reached. But is it? No, we are left with Schmidt saying 'I don't know who Erich Hartmann was, but he was on the Nazi's side, so he must have been bad'.

In the end, I wish I could have my money back. This was a magazine article that Schmidt wrapped Erich Hartmann's name around so Schmidt could sell it for money. I would like to return the book but my conscience won't let me.

Please do not give Erik Schmidt money for this.

Note: My knowledge of this subject spans 20 years and over 130 books on WWII and its airwar. Including the majority of the books Schmidt references.

29 people found this helpful

Helpful

Andrew J Dugger

Thoughtful Biography

Reviewed in the United States on April 11, 2020

Verified Purchase

This was a very good read. I tend to not like biographies sometimes because they seem to come with an agenda. I felt the author did a good job of seeing the world and Erich Hartmann objectively. When the subject of the biography was a Nazi fighter pilot there are some really loaded places to take the narrative. But I felt the author did a good job of placing things in context. He didn't shy away from the hard questions but then again didn't force feed any answers to them either. Personally I appreciate that. The author is both talented and objective...a great combination. I would highly recommend the book.

4 people found this helpful

Helpful

Andrew

it’s ok!

Reviewed in the United States on February 26, 2024

Verified Purchase

The book it’s entertaining enough and the author obviously puts much thought into it and writes in an honest manner. Unfortunately it’s hampered by the excessive complaining about other books written on the subject matter.

Helpful

Top reviews from other countries

C. T.

More like a psychology thesis

Reviewed in Canada on April 20, 2021

Verified Purchase

Not at all what I was expecting - spends more time on the social / psychological background of Germany than actually dealing with Hartman. Definitely would not recommend - would give it a 0 star rating if I could.

kstk

Not much about Hartmann

Reviewed in Spain on February 9, 2022

Verified Purchase

The Author leverage's Hartmann topic, to write his thoughs and opinions over several WW2 topics and about other Authors books.
It surprised me how little about Hartmann is contained in this book.

Carlos Priego

Absolute waste of time.

Reviewed in Mexico on October 4, 2020

Verified Purchase

You start very excited about probably learning something new about thelis fighter ace.
Then you realize: An absolute misleading title.
It spends more than a third of the book discussing and cursing the Nazis rise to power and government, criticizing his first biographers and trying to make you feel guilt (a sort if criminal collaborationist) for admiring german veterans.
A sorry try to convince the reader in why you should not praise german combatants and their memorabilia. A sort of personal hate...

Mikey D

This is NOT a biography of Erich Hartmann

Reviewed in the United Kingdom on May 25, 2020

Verified Purchase

According to the Amazon blurb this book "started out as a grad-school thesis". And boy does it read like it. This is most definitely not a conventional biography. In fact, the name Erich Hartmann is often not even mentioned on many pages of this book (which, despite the Amazon claim of 240 pages is actually only 212 pages including endnotes, bibliography and index).
If you want to know about Erich Hartmann you would be much better off looking at Wikipedia - where it is told in a much more interesting way. The author is big on historical context but small on biographical detail.
He spends too much time trying to debunk the first real Hartmann biography by Toliver and Constable: "The Blond Knight of Germany", but manages direct quotes from the book and also paraphrases many of the T&C anecdotes. In fact, out of 319 endnotes a total of 53 are for "The Blond Knight of Germany".
His research is pretty poor. There are two mentions that he makes about talking to locals from Hartmann's hometown that bookend the story. The first one is a waitress and he freely admits his knowledge of German is too poor and he fails to ask all the questions he wanted to. The last one is about two women tending graves in the cemetery where Erich Hartmann is buried. Again he freely admits that his poor German lets him down again. So the only two actual interviews he admits to are both failures.
His research is very limited. He mentions fellow JG52 pilot Hermann Graf briefly but has clearly not read "Oberst Hermann Graf: 200 Luftsiege in 13 Monaten" which he could have used very constructively in helping to tell part of the story. And to avoid utilising the Bernd Barbas book on Hartmann's primary unit: "Die Geschichte der III.Gruppe des JG52" is poor judgement and downright lazy.
In conclusion I would say that this is a pointless purchase if you want the story of the life, career and motivations of Erich Hartmann. But if you want a dry grad-school thesis then go right ahead.

15 people found this helpful

Kindle Customer

Opinionated author

Reviewed in Canada on March 24, 2021

Verified Purchase

A very big disappointment, excepted a book about Hartmann and his life. Instead all I got was the authors opinions loaded with inaccurate information. The only interesting part was imprisonment in the USSR.

See more reviews